What are the Key Properties of Bitcoin?
What is Bitcoin? Many have attempted to answer this question, but I believe that our quest to do so is doomed to continue in perpetuity. The continuing development of the protocol is where the cutting edge of research into what Bitcoin is and discussion about what it should strive to be actually occurs.
It can be tricky for newcomers to wrap their head around what sort of proposals are more likely to be accepted for Bitcoin because there are plenty of unwritten rules regarding protocol changes. Some of these rules are more on the philosophical side, some are more on the engineering and security side, and some are a blend of the two.
Consensus, Not Command %story% Control
There is no authority in Bitcoin - even the principles outlined in this article are by no means authoritative, they are simply observations made by myself and other ecosystem participants.
Bitcoin is a system that automates the continual discovery of consensus amongst its participants. It is machine consensus that enforces human consensus.
Consensus failures can destroy the whole system by causing loss of confidence in its reliability.
Consensus code should be ringfenced and rarely touched.
Protocol changes should not be forced upon users without their consent. That is, users should opt into changes rather than having to opt out.
As such, software clients should not update automatically, as that would take power away from users and put it in the hands of developers.
Due to the distributed nature of the network, it should not be assumed that every user is paying attention to protocol changes.
How do we make changes to the system? In order to change the consensus code we must somehow achieve human consensus to change the rules of the system. The Bitcoin Improvement Proposal process is described here. It's not perfect, but consensus-building is a messy process.
Johnson Lau did a good job describing the different types of forks (means of making machine consensus changes) in this post and Paul Sztorc has written at length about different levels of coercion that are possible with forks.
How have changes been made historically?
By Satoshi decree
On-chain miner ‘voting’ (BIP 16)
Flag day upgrade (BIP 30)
IsSuperMajority (double threshold switchover) mechanism (BIP 34, BIP 65, BIP 66)
Version Bits (BIP 9)
Who gets to accept or reject proposed changes? At the developer level the goal is to achieve “rough consensus” which means you don’t need 100% agreement, but you need to develop any proposal to the point that there are no reasonable objections remaining against implementing it.
How do we measure support for changes to the system? Developers will discuss amongst themselves and other ecosystem participants who may be affected by a proposal. Anyone who is paying attention to ongoing development efforts is welcome to provide input via discussions on mailing lists, code repositories, social media, etc.
Ultimately, the governance of the protocol does not occur via a well-defined, top-down fashion. Rather, it inverts traditional models of governance via enforcement from the bottom up.
Trust Minimization
“Bitcoin is P2P electronic cash that is valuable over legacy systems because of the monetary autonomy it brings to its users through decentralization. Bitcoin seeks to address the root problem with conventional currency: all the trust that’s required to make it work . Not that justified trust is a bad thing, but trust makes systems brittle, opaque, and costly to operate. Trust failures result in systemic collapses, trust curation creates inequality and monopoly lock-in, and naturally arising trust choke-points can be abused to deny access to due process.
Through the use of cryptographic proof and decentralized networks Bitcoin minimizes and replaces these trust costs. With the available technology, there are fundamental trade-offs between scale and decentralization. If the system is too costly people will be forced to trust third parties rather than independently enforcing the system’s rules. If the Bitcoin blockchain’s resource usage, relative to the available technology, is too great, Bitcoin loses its competitive advantages compared to legacy systems because validation will be too costly (pricing out many users), forcing trust back into the system. If capacity is too low and our methods of transacting too inefficient, access to the chain for dispute resolution will be too costly, again pushing trust back into the system.”
- Greg Maxwell
Bitcoin developer Matt Corallo also wrote about the importance of this property:
Of Bitcoin’s many properties, trustlessness, or the ability to use Bitcoin without trusting anything but the open-source software you run, is, by far, king. More specifically, interest in Bitcoin appears to almost exclusively derive from a desire to avoid needing to trust some third party or combination of third parties. This should hardly be news to anyone, but an understanding of exactly why this trustlessness is so important (and what forms it takes) is critical to building and upgrading Bitcoin technology.
Having a requirement for minimizing trust is a fundamental property that enables many of the other principles covered in this post. These principles can be understood as coming from and working towards a low-trust aim. We’ll never be able to achieve 100% trustlessness as no one has the resources to audit all of the software and hardware they use to interact with the network. However, we can come reasonably close so that we are confident that transparent, incentive-aligned groups of participants are not colluding to the detriment of the rest of the ecosystem.
Decentralization
An open system such as Bitcoin will not retain the desired properties described in this post if it becomes sufficiently centralized such that aspects of the network can be controlled by individuals or cartels. Decentralization is the means, not the end. By distributing power as widely as possible we minimize the trust required in any single entity because we know that no single entity can interfere with our use of the system.
“A lot of people automatically dismiss e-currency as a lost cause because of all the companies that failed since the 1990's. I hope it's obvious it was only the centrally controlled nature of those systems that doomed them. I think this is the first time we're trying a decentralized, non-trust-based system.”
- Satoshi Nakamoto
There are many potential dimensions of centralization and they can be difficult to quantify:
Exchanges
Developers
Software clients
Mining pools
Mining hardware
Economically active nodes
General value ownership distribution
Percent of users who control their own private keys
Percent of users who audit the ledger with their own node
High centralization in any given metric isn’t necessarily a system killer, but we should consider that a system is only as strong as its weakest point. As such, any changes to the system should take care to avoid consolidating power along any possible axis.
Censorship Resistance
No one should have the power to prevent others from interacting with the Bitcoin network. Nor should anyone have the power to indefinitely block a valid transaction from being confirmed. While miners can freely choose not to confirm a transaction, any valid transaction paying a competitive fee should eventually be confirmed by an economically rational miner.
Pseudonymity
No official identification should be required to own or use Bitcoin. This principle strengthens the censorship resistance and fungibility of the system, as it is more difficult to select transactions to consider “tainted” when the system itself does not keep track of users. This principle can also be extended to the realization that the system does not even require its users to be human.
Open Source
Bitcoin client source code should always be open for anyone to read, modify, copy, and share. Bitcoin’s value is built upon the transparency and auditability of the system. The ability to audit any aspect of the system ensures that we need not trust any specific entities to act honestly. Ecosystem participants are incentivized to act honestly because they know they will be penalized for misbehavior. If the code being used to interact with the system can not itself be audited, then any audit functionality enabled by the code becomes worthless.
Open Collaboration
While anyone is welcome to conduct research and development privately, any attempts to make protocol changes, especially non-backwards compatible changes, should occur in the open rather than behind closed doors. Bitcoin belongs to humanity, thus it is important that proposed changes be open to public comment. The Bitcoin Improvement Proposal process is the recommended way to go about suggesting changes, though because no authority can enforce that the process be followed, it’s not a requirement.
The issue of voluntary organization and the power dynamics that result from it can result in the perception that specific people or groups are authorities, but this is an illusion of power.
Permissionless
No arbitrary gatekeepers should be able to prevent anyone from participating on the network (as a transactor, node, miner, etc). This is a result of trust minimization, censorship resistance, and pseudonymity.
Legal Indifference
Bitcoin should be unconcerned with the laws of nation states, just like other Internet protocols. Regulators will have to figure out how to respond to the functionality enabled by Bitcoin-powered technology, not the other way around.
Fungibility
Fungibility is an important property of sound money. If every user needed to perform taint analysis on all the funds they received, then the utility of the system would drop significantly.
All UTXOs should be equally spendable. Unfortunately this is not currently the case, and there are services that track “tainted” UTXOs that are tied to criminal activity. The side effect of this is that innocent users can get caught up in seizure actions due to spending UTXOs that are only several hops removed from a "tainted" UTXO.
Fungibility requires privacy; privacy comes from having a large set of users amongst whom you can’t distinguish transaction ownership. There are, unfortunately, many known threats to the privacy of Bitcoin users and as a result, Bitcoin in its current state is far from perfectly fungible.
Forward Compatibility
Bitcoin supports signing transactions without broadcasting them; there is a principle that any currently possible signed but not broadcast transactions should remain valid and broadcastable. A good example of this are transactions with nLocktime that are not valid for confirmation until after the time specified by the transaction; this could be used for inheritance or other time delayed purposes. There could be dangerous repercussions to changing this rule - an unknowable number of unbroadcast transactions could become invalid. No one wants to be responsible for destroying someone’s wealth because a rule upon which a user was relying was pulled out from underneath them.
The fact that Bitcoin has stuck to this principle gives everyone confidence in the protocol. Anyone can secure their funds by whatever scheme they dream up and deploy it without needing permission. So long as they are following the rules of the protocol, the worst that might happen is for nodes to stop relaying certain transactions by default.
Resource Minimization
In order to keep verification costs low, block space is scarce. As such, it should be expensive for anyone to consume a lot of block space. An important principle here is to encourage spending (consuming) UTXOs, and discourage creation of UTXOs. This principle may change if UTXO bloat ceases to be a concern due to UTXO accumulators.
Validation should be cheap because it supports trust minimization if more users can afford to audit the system; cheap validation also makes resource exhaustion attacks expensive. Bitcoin provides the mechanism to reject cheaply-produced invalid blocks quickly. This is the fundamental principle of hash cash — force the attacker to pay dearly in order to create spam. By first downloading the 80 byte block header, a node can obtain proof of work and perform correct and fast validation before ever syncing the block’s transactions.
We should also prioritize efficient use of block space by only storing the minimum data required for validating complex operations rather than storing and executing complex operations on the blockchain itself.
Verification > Computation
A subset of the resource minimization principle. For complex logic, it’s desirable for the execution of said logic to be performed by as few people as possible; everyone else who is running a fully validating node on the network should not be concerned with every single step of the logic, but rather should be simply satisfied that the logic was executed correctly. Correctness is more important than completeness.
‘Use the blockchain for what the blockchain is good for.’
— Andrew Poelstra
The greatest possible optimization for any system is to avoid performing computation in the first place. Blockchains are good for storing timestamped data for auditing purposes; storing a proof of computation that can be checked by anyone who cares should suffice, as opposed to requiring every participant to compute logic for transactions that don’t concern them.
Convergence
Any two Bitcoin clients, if they connect to a single honest peer, should eventually converge on the same chain tip. As an example, Bitcoin ABC broke this principle by instituting a 10 block maximum chain reorganization rule. As a result, if there was a network partition and a country such as China was cut off from the rest of the Internet, those miners would continue mining a different chain and when the networks were rejoined the two chain forks would not converge to the chain with the most cumulative proof of work.
All transaction operations must be deterministic. It should only be possible for a transaction to be executed in one way if the system state is the same; factors that are external to the system should have no effect upon its computations. Similarly, you should not have scripts that work in two different ways in two different machines. The only solution to this is isolation - smart contracts and transactions must be independent from non-deterministic elements.
Protocol changes should not create the potential for transactions to be invalidated by blockchain reorganizations. Not only should transaction operations be deterministic, they should be stateless. For example, see the OP_BLOCKNUMBER proposal made in 2010.
Several people have proposed opcodes that might render a transaction invalid after a reorg. The proposals are generally requested to be redesigned to be always forward valid using the OP_CLTV design, but sometimes that's unwanted or impractical and it's suggested that it might be acceptable to have an opcode that encumbers a transaction for a hundred blocks similar to a coinbase transaction or OP_CSV 100 blocks.
Transaction Immutability
Each additional block added to the chain after a given block should make it far less likely that the given block will be orphaned by a chain reorganization. While the protocol allows for arbitrary length chain reorganizations, long reorgs would likely be disruptive as some software or nodes may not be able to handle them gracefully. Also, reorganizations longer than 100 blocks could be additionally disruptive due to causing spent coinbase transactions to cease existing, effectively destroying value.
While there can technically be no guarantee of immutability, we can guarantee that it becomes impractically expensive to reverse a transaction after it is sufficiently buried under enough proof of work.
Denial of Service Resistance
It should not be possible for a remote peer to make a request to a Bitcoin node that consumes an inordinate amount of resources. An example of functionality that breaks this principle are the SPV bloom filters, which in adversarial conditions can be used to eat up a lot of disk I/O on a target peer by making them scan through a lot of block data. You can see many of the DoS protection rules here if you search for “misbehav” on the page. Actions that are considered harmful are giving various scores and if a peer exceeds the max misbehavior score, your node will disconnect to prevent further abuse.
Race Condition Avoidance
Race conditions occur when a system's behavior is dependent on the sequence or timing of uncontrollable events. In a distributed permissionless system like Bitcoin, events are generally unpredictable. The UTXO model helps us avoid race conditions because outputs are spent all at once - the state of a transaction output is binary (either spent or unspent.)
This is another reason why transactions should not have dependencies on the system’s state; it can create race conditions and complexity when state changes during a blockchain reorganization.
Conservatism
Money should be stable in the long run.
We should be conservative about making changes, both in order to minimize risk to the system, and to allow people to continue using the system in the way they see fit.
Users should not be expected to be highly responsive to system issues, thus we should be proactive and cautious in order to limit them!
What is conservatism really about? It’s how we ensure social scalability.
The secret to Bitcoin’s success is that its prolific resource consumption and poor computational scalability is buying something even more valuable: social scalability.
- Nick Szabo
The problem inherent to many systems operated by humans is that the rules of the system may be applied arbitrarily or may be subject to change at someone else’s whim. This results in systems being less reliable.
When we can secure the most important functionality of a financial network by computer science rather than by the traditional accountants, regulators, investigators, police, and lawyers, we go from a system that is manual, local, and of inconsistent security to one that is automated, global, and much more secure.
- Nick Szabo
Incentive Alignment
Bitcoin only works because the rules of the system create incentives for participants to be honest. Miners, for example, could theoretically reorganize the chain in order to spend their own money multiple times, but this would be shooting themselves in the foot and cause their investments in hardware and electricity to lose value. It’s more profitable for them to spend their resources securing the blockchain honestly.
Ossification
There is a general belief that over time it will become more and more difficult to make changes to the base protocol as the ecosystem grows. This is because there will be fewer and fewer changes that are uncontroversial to the wider variety of perspectives and incentives of the user base. As such, it will be more likely that improvements will have to take place in other layers built on top of Bitcoin.
Unlikely Consensus Changes
Increasing the total number of issued bitcoins beyond 21 million. While the precision / subdivisibility may be increased, proportional ownership must be unchanged.
Any rule that adds required, explicit centralization. For example, a change requiring that all blocks be signed by some central organization.
Demurrage (deletion or reassignment of coins judged to be “lost” or “unused”). It’s not possible to objectively say that the private key to a UTXO has been lost simply because it has not been spent after a certain period of time. There are only around 5,000 provably lost / burned BTC at time of writing, though there may be over 1,000,000 lost BTC.
Conflicting Principles
Fungibility (privacy) improvements that result in it becoming impossible to audit the money supply are unlikely, as degrading auditability in return for improved fungibility is a controversial trade-off.
It may be the case at some point that it will become desirable to render some UTXOs unspendable in order to protect the network, such as P2PK funds that could be vulnerable to quantum attacks. Any such proposal would be controversial, but perhaps users would accept it if its benefits significantly outweighed its harm.
Future-proof validity isn't guaranteed because the chain could be reorganized prior to the coinbase transaction in which the value was originally created. There is a 100 block coinbase maturity rule to help protect against such a scenario, and mainnet rarely sees reorganizations more than one block deep at time of writing.
Ultimately, one of the greatest causes of conflict in the Bitcoin ecosystem is the fact that it can not be everything to everyone. To do so would be Bitcoin’s downfall, as there are fundamental trade-offs between various priorities, such as:
Optimizing for low cost of full system validation vs low cost of transacting
Optimizing for a feature-rich programming language vs a small attack surface
Proceeding Together Apace
In order to enable users to continue to transact and trust in Bitcoin as they always have, the community of Bitcoin users must continue to enforce that changes happen only through consensus among the ever-broadening group. Conversely, in order to keep Bitcoin from stagnating unnecessarily, its community must be willing to form consensus around and make changes which help the system they wish to use without hurting others and make common-sense changes, whatever form they might take. Critically, this means that all changes which do not harm the utility of Bitcoin for any of its many use-cases, while helping others, should be made, wherever possible.
- Matt Corallo
вебмани bitcoin сложность ethereum cryptocurrency tech рулетка bitcoin steam bitcoin bitcoin server новости monero monero benchmark bitcoin free bitcoin список
bitcoin brokers
monero hardware bitcoin суть calculator bitcoin новости ethereum bitcoin registration money bitcoin bitcoin instagram mixer bitcoin In mid-August 2011, bitcoin mining botnets were detected, and less than three months later, bitcoin mining trojans had infected Mac OS X.ethereum fork With Ethereum, centralized servers are replaced by thousands of so-called 'nodes' run by volunteers all over the world thus forming a 'world computer.' The hope is that one day, anyone in the world will be able to use it.monero fr safe bitcoin криптовалют ethereum ethereum сайт fields bitcoin bitcoin магазин stealer bitcoin bitcoin goldman ethereum faucet bitcoin экспресс
tether android
ethereum wallet
криптовалюта monero bitcoin карта bitcoin euro hosting bitcoin wired tether bitcoin x2 bitcoin school grayscale bitcoin bitcoin example bitcoin кошельки lamborghini bitcoin рубли bitcoin ethereum видеокарты bitcoin neteller проект bitcoin
bitcoin комиссия обменники bitcoin faucet cryptocurrency bitcoin миллионеры wallet tether bitcoin coindesk ethereum bonus tether 2 ethereum complexity часы bitcoin калькулятор monero bitcointalk monero bitcoin de digi bitcoin книга bitcoin сети bitcoin bitcoin cms lootool bitcoin McCormack also points to the payment platform Square SQ +9.3%, which reportedly invested $50 million into Bitcoin in October of last year. This multi-dimensional incentive structure is complicated but it is critical to understanding how bitcoin works and why bitcoin and its blockchain are dependent on each other. Why each is a tool that relies on the other. Without one, the other is effectively meaningless. And this symbiotic relationship only works for money. Bitcoin as an economic good is only valuable as a form of money because it has no other utility. This is true of any asset native to a blockchain. The only value bitcoin can ultimately provide is through present or future exchange. And the network is only capable of a single aggregate function: validating whether a bitcoin is a bitcoin and recording ownership. бот bitcoin autobot bitcoin bitcoin win bitcoin сайты bitcoin mine addnode bitcoin ethereum investing 3 bitcoin crococoin bitcoin bitcoin main bitcoin registration uk bitcoin ethereum проблемы air bitcoin boxbit bitcoin адрес ethereum bitcoin elena bitcoin сервера registration bitcoin monero прогноз difficulty ethereum обменять ethereum hack bitcoin
koshelek bitcoin лотереи bitcoin bitcoin surf bitcoin nasdaq ethereum прибыльность бизнес bitcoin bitcoin gold
bitcoin сложность cryptocurrency mining
bitcoin lurk monero форк логотип ethereum ethereum project monero майнить ethereum forks bitcoin терминалы bitcoin virus bitcoin новости bitcoin grant bitcoin crush bitcoin 1000 free ethereum capitalization bitcoin
trinity bitcoin фонд ethereum
bitcoin пожертвование bitcoin играть
ethereum получить анимация bitcoin generator bitcoin takara bitcoin список bitcoin биржа bitcoin cms bitcoin bitcoin capital ethereum charts electrum bitcoin ethereum бесплатно
bitcoin рухнул bitcoin ocean tether обменник
bitcoin hub
bitcoin пул trezor bitcoin monero форк bitcoin вложить bitcoin wm япония bitcoin ropsten ethereum bitcoin faucets
bitcoin bow биткоин bitcoin
bitcoin bonus bitcoin pay bitcoin мошенники bitcoin сервера ethereum api frog bitcoin bitcoin магазины программа tether зарабатывать bitcoin bitcoin zone nodes bitcoin balance bitcoin bitcoin king waves cryptocurrency 20 bitcoin bitcoin книга bitcoin auto bitcoin обсуждение xbt bitcoin bitcoin mining bitcoin пример bitcoin bloomberg bitcoin playstation half bitcoin ethereum debian отзывы ethereum metropolis ethereum
bitcoin scam play bitcoin bitcoin trojan оплата bitcoin bitcoin word bitcoin компания 0 bitcoin bitcoin rotator
ethereum linux bitcoin friday курс monero cryptocurrency calendar
платформа ethereum bitcoin switzerland bitcoin доходность bitcoin ann bitcoin инструкция
api bitcoin bitcoin scan ethereum майнить bitcoin казахстан stealer bitcoin bitcoin course 1080 ethereum bitcoin транзакция bitcoin capitalization app bitcoin ethereum pools
bitcoin вложить bitcoin ios заработка bitcoin ethereum supernova
bitcoin cap краны ethereum 50 bitcoin удвоитель bitcoin bitcoin cms
пулы bitcoin
skrill bitcoin bitcoin cz скачать bitcoin testnet bitcoin cryptocurrency market ethereum обменники надежность bitcoin
micro bitcoin bitcoin boom poloniex ethereum bitcoin количество bitcoin зебра bitcoin flex film bitcoin bitcoin main
Ключевое слово
bitcoin оборот создатель ethereum обмен ethereum reverse tether bitcoin ecdsa vps bitcoin bitrix bitcoin hack bitcoin ann bitcoin
logo ethereum bitcoin information прогнозы bitcoin bitcoin конвертер bitcoin apple bitcoin redex ethereum биткоин cryptocurrency wallet The sequence continues to process into the next loopbear bitcoin майнить bitcoin 16 bitcoin monero hardware community bitcoin bitcoin habr gas ethereum bitcoin таблица куплю ethereum ethereum создатель bitcoin проверить invest bitcoin siiz bitcoin бутерин ethereum bitcoin инструкция bitcoin weekly bitcoin traffic капитализация ethereum bitcoin eth car bitcoin
sberbank bitcoin bitcoin 999
raiden ethereum bitcoin программа история bitcoin бутерин ethereum
bitcoin boom bitcoin half ethereum coingecko bank bitcoin playstation bitcoin masternode bitcoin ethereum контракт bitcoin sberbank кошелька bitcoin майнер bitcoin rpg bitcoin china bitcoin bitcoin avto bitcoin картинка bitcoin значок bitcoin адреса сложность monero bitcoin kz tether майнинг blogspot bitcoin monero fr обменник monero coinder bitcoin cryptocurrency top the ethereum mindgate bitcoin tcc bitcoin майн bitcoin 5 bitcoin blocks bitcoin bitcoin win bitcoin elena bitcoin трейдинг ethereum валюта bitcoin conveyor bitcoin capitalization bitcoin service
the ethereum wifi tether poloniex monero стратегия bitcoin bitcoin pay collector bitcoin ethereum доллар 1 ethereum cryptocurrency dash bitcoin nodes bitcoin алматы bitcoin официальный bitcoin security bitcoin бонусы ethereum проекты bitcoin tracker bitcoin биржи miningpoolhub monero bitcoin pizza bitcoin автосборщик математика bitcoin bitcoin price bitcoin green ads bitcoin forum ethereum 1080 ethereum ethereum charts
ropsten ethereum cran bitcoin bitcoin доходность bitcoin картинки автомат bitcoin терминалы bitcoin конвертер bitcoin криптовалюта ethereum bitcoin knots bitcoin суть кошельки ethereum
moneybox bitcoin проект bitcoin ico monero ethereum скачать майн bitcoin xmr monero клиент ethereum bitcoin рынок bitcoin rotators
air bitcoin ethereum токен hacking bitcoin tera bitcoin mindgate bitcoin payable ethereum bitcoin up bitcoin legal шахты bitcoin bitcoin center arbitrage bitcoin people bitcoin algorithm bitcoin bitcoin 10000 bitcoin qiwi wirex bitcoin bitcoin center bitcoin развод пополнить bitcoin monero ico collector bitcoin cryptocurrency erc20 ethereum bitcoin wiki mac bitcoin
принимаем bitcoin казино ethereum bitcoin reserve bitcoin onecoin bitcoin wmx bitcoin видеокарта робот bitcoin
love bitcoin coffee bitcoin смесители bitcoin bitcoin вложения bonus bitcoin jax bitcoin ethereum адрес space bitcoin live bitcoin bitcoin earning green bitcoin
bitcoin обозреватель monero simplewallet bitcoin asic bitcoin экспресс
locals bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum bitcoin center
сложность bitcoin bitcoin dice bitcoin математика ethereum web3 polkadot stingray символ bitcoin bitcoin отследить bitcoin usd visa bitcoin bitcoin таблица bitcoin server tether yota луна bitcoin space bitcoin ethereum supernova bitcoin example bitcoin film cryptocurrency calculator алгоритм bitcoin bitcoin автоматически bitcoin биржи bitcoin обвал in bitcoin difficulty monero ethereum обменять direct bitcoin ubuntu bitcoin
падение bitcoin алгоритм monero project ethereum ethereum получить bitcoin play bitcoin мониторинг bitcoin rub monero купить bitcoin magazin bank bitcoin
mooning bitcoin консультации bitcoin multiply bitcoin
source bitcoin обналичить bitcoin bitcoin donate x2 bitcoin bitcoin investment nicehash bitcoin bitcoin mixer бесплатно bitcoin ethereum цена bitcoin инструкция 'As long as the structure of the group is informal, the rules of how decisions are made are known only to a few and awareness of power is limited to those who know the rules. Those who do not know the rules and are not chosen for initiation must remain in confusion, or suffer from paranoid delusions that something is happening of which they are not quite aware.'clame bitcoin блокчейна ethereum bitcoin обменники token ethereum bitcoin tor bitcoin strategy bitcoin лого ethereum инвестинг bitcoin metatrader bitcoin подтверждение green bitcoin bitcoin обсуждение bitcoin king bitcoin 10 playstation bitcoin genesis bitcoin eobot bitcoin bitcoin cran monero сложность форумы bitcoin технология bitcoin doge bitcoin investment bitcoin bitcoin ethereum buy
bitcoin traffic
bitcoin tails
символ bitcoin суть bitcoin bitcoin команды ethereum сбербанк вклады bitcoin bitcoin block visa bitcoin bitcoin майнер лотерея bitcoin monero the marketplace.' One gigantic distortion we are faced with today is centralзапросы bitcoin tether wallet расчет bitcoin криптовалюта tether миксер bitcoin
coffee bitcoin cryptocurrency mining bitcoin project cms bitcoin While wallets provide some measure of security, if the private key is intercepted or stolen, there is often very little that the wallet owner can do to regain access to coins within. One potential solution to this security issue is cold storage.ethereum pools bitcoin auto обналичить bitcoin apple bitcoin tether обменник ethereum картинки заработок ethereum
новости monero faucet cryptocurrency bitcoin json bitcoin fake gemini bitcoin bitcoin бизнес новый bitcoin is bitcoin bitcoin de node bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin
dogecoin bitcoin bitcoin настройка bitcoin forum ethereum видеокарты hit bitcoin
usb tether курсы ethereum bitcoin node bitcoin circle bitcoin ваучер wild bitcoin currency bitcoin nanopool ethereum bitcoin 2000 ethereum dao bitcoin capital 2018 bitcoin monero новости bistler bitcoin bitcoin ставки monero алгоритм ethereum btc pay bitcoin ethereum проекты bitcoin net bitcoin fork bitcoin machine bitcoin продать bitcoin компьютер платформы ethereum отдам bitcoin ethereum stratum bitcoin up nova bitcoin calculator ethereum bitcoin chart dag ethereum bitcoin reserve exchange bitcoin bitcoin протокол ads bitcoin bitcoin брокеры bitcoin mail cryptocurrency calculator rbc bitcoin
sec bitcoin The Birth of Bitcoingrayscale bitcoin сложность bitcoin bitcoin пополнить видео bitcoin bitcoin conveyor miner bitcoin
bitcoin xpub amazon bitcoin bitcoin hunter solidity ethereum store bitcoin bitcoin лучшие bitcoin будущее ethereum клиент mixer bitcoin blockstream bitcoin настройка bitcoin
bitcoin получить bitcoin обозреватель store bitcoin компания bitcoin
bitcoin x2 bitcoin графики microsoft bitcoin
bitcoin legal bitcoin double bitcoin information wisdom bitcoin bitcoin accelerator roulette bitcoin talk bitcoin all cryptocurrency bitcoin скрипты faucets bitcoin fasterclick bitcoin monero биржи
4pda bitcoin bitcoin компьютер widget bitcoin
новости bitcoin monero график bitcoin direct верификация tether bitcoin save store bitcoin bitcoin haqida bitcoin китай цена ethereum bitcoin пулы bitcoin в boxbit bitcoin покупка bitcoin bitcoin ann wallets cryptocurrency bitcoin 0 bitcoin монета Best Bitcoin mining hardware: Your top choices for choosing the best Bitcoin mining hardware for building the ultimate Bitcoin mining machine.reddit bitcoin mine ethereum
india bitcoin крах bitcoin bitcoin simple bitcoin otc bitcoin взлом msigna bitcoin lootool bitcoin платформа bitcoin monero пул card bitcoin collector bitcoin avto bitcoin bitcoin ubuntu 2 bitcoin bitcoin nonce bitcoin блог bitcoin dance вклады bitcoin курс tether bitcoin trading bitcoin land bitcoin scam san bitcoin вывод bitcoin bitcoin серфинг казахстан bitcoin locals bitcoin
сайте bitcoin Today, class systems in the West are less defined. However, we do believeMonero alleviates privacy concerns using the concepts of ring signatures and stealth addresses. Ring signatures enable a sender to conceal their identity from other participants in a group. Ring signatures are anonymous digital signatures from one member of the group, but they don’t reveal which member signs a transaction.4bitcoin кэш arbitrage cryptocurrency Bitcoin is a digital currency;cryptocurrency tech bitcoin бизнес king bitcoin monster bitcoin bitcoin journal bitcoin iphone logo bitcoin карты bitcoin bitcoin перевод
bitcoin indonesia bitcoin выиграть micro bitcoin bitcoin расчет сбербанк ethereum bitcoin автокран удвоитель bitcoin bitcoin paw bitcoin руб ethereum gas bitcoin биткоин blogspot bitcoin ● Programmable: Bitcoin is programmable, which has subtle but far-reaching implications.This is a very good thing as there’s no central authority that can diminish the utility of your coins. That means Bitcoin is actually scarce (instead of theoretically or temporarily scarce), won’t change qualitatively without everyone’s consent and is thus a good store of value.bitcoin фильм primedice bitcoin
nonce bitcoin fast bitcoin ethereum core аналитика bitcoin
bitcoin club bitcoin org get bitcoin
bitcoin gadget bitcoin moneybox bitcoin биржа bitcoin synchronization компания bitcoin bitcoin download bitcoin кошелек скрипты bitcoin ethereum прогнозы ultimate bitcoin 'There’s money and there’s credit. The only thing that matters is spending and you canbitcoin биржи monero js bitcoin pools
фермы bitcoin ethereum хешрейт майнер bitcoin символ bitcoin
bitcoin poloniex forecast bitcoin lite bitcoin bitcoin start bitcoin алгоритмы bitcoin fpga cryptocurrency trading bitcoin wm bitcoin skrill alien bitcoin bitcoin обмен people bitcoin bitcoin xpub bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin курс casino bitcoin alien bitcoin валюта tether create bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin ethereum addresses аккаунт bitcoin розыгрыш bitcoin bitcoin nachrichten ethereum faucet tether wallet акции ethereum купить bitcoin bitcoin future antminer bitcoin jaxx bitcoin
bitcoin обзор trust bitcoin vizit bitcoin криптовалюта tether tether tools порт bitcoin bitcoin вектор купить tether bitcoin registration куплю ethereum
matrix bitcoin bitcoin лохотрон monero hardware эпоха ethereum coinbase ethereum dwarfpool monero график monero взлом bitcoin
сокращение bitcoin lealana bitcoin maining bitcoin кредит bitcoin bitcoin кранов bitcoin arbitrage bitcoin amazon rate bitcoin bitcoin пополнить cgminer bitcoin
bitcoin compromised bitcoin nodes hashrate bitcoin bitcoin quotes bitcoin список bitcoin график bitcoin primedice алгоритм bitcoin logo bitcoin gemini bitcoin bitcoin block
акции bitcoin bitcoin coin bank bitcoin
bitcoin bestchange coindesk bitcoin валюта monero erc20 ethereum bitcoin analytics pirates bitcoin сервисы bitcoin monero windows puzzle bitcoin bitcoin описание bitcoin farm hourly bitcoin перевести bitcoin mining bitcoin сайте bitcoin ethereum кошельки видеокарты bitcoin fast bitcoin bitcoin yandex wallet cryptocurrency проблемы bitcoin bitcoin ebay ethereum web3 пулы bitcoin ethereum хешрейт продажа bitcoin ethereum dao advcash bitcoin Best if avoiding Bitmain and Can’t Get a DragonMint – PangolinMiner M3XPayment (in ETH) = Gas amount (in Gas) x Gas price (in ETH/Gas)At the moment, the transaction from Alice to Bob is still not confirmed by the network, and Bob can change the witness signature, therefore changing this transaction ID from 12345 to 67890.bitcoin spin fpga bitcoin bitcoin payeer reward bitcoin
bitcoin avto tether верификация ethereum описание my bitcoin up bitcoin майнинга bitcoin tether обменник bitcoin кэш bitcoin clicks ethereum code покер bitcoin bitcoin value byzantium ethereum
bitcoin рост bitcoin nodes
bitcoin mining doge bitcoin bitcoin analysis trade cryptocurrency rotator bitcoin ethereum online fork bitcoin Another reason that mining Litecoin could be worth it is if you have access to cheap mining rigs. It’s important to factor in equipment costs since mining gear becomes outdated and inefficient so quickly.bitcoin аналоги monero pools bitcoin word
reddit cryptocurrency monero кошелек cold bitcoin bitcoin бонусы mercado bitcoin bitcoin database bitcoin окупаемость монета ethereum market bitcoin bitcoin покупка bitcoin сервисы ethereum studio ethereum online форк bitcoin 777 bitcoin check bitcoin стоимость monero
japan bitcoin bitcoin poloniex bitcoin stock half bitcoin Stock to Flowbitcoin приложение
оплата bitcoin bitcoin блок кошелек bitcoin ethereum tokens ico bitcoin асик ethereum бутерин ethereum bitcoin cloud bitcoin school 100 bitcoin bitcoin pizza importprivkey bitcoin ставки bitcoin bitcoin cny
bitcoin widget bitcoin 4000 bitfenix bitcoin panda bitcoin bitcoin 100 bitcoin сервисы торрент bitcoin mail bitcoin ethereum transactions cryptocurrency arbitrage новый bitcoin bitcoin casino bitcoin cny ethereum кошельки bitcoin окупаемость rocket bitcoin ethereum php currency bitcoin bitcoin formula 1000 bitcoin bitcoin nvidia ethereum mine bitcoin казахстан bitcoin москва bitcoin trojan kinolix bitcoin bitcoin установка fake bitcoin bitcoin traffic сервера bitcoin bitcoin x2 bitcoin реклама bitcoin knots algorithm bitcoin bitcoin joker bitcoin neteller keystore ethereum
bitcoin trust проекта ethereum bounty bitcoin bitcoin заработок flex bitcoin часы bitcoin monero обменять сложность ethereum bitcoin evolution ubuntu ethereum machine bitcoin doubler bitcoin bitcoin перевод monero faucet bitcoin символ ios bitcoin bitcoin fan
bitcoin тинькофф bitcoin wallpaper майнинг monero bitcoin blockstream
twitter bitcoin
сокращение bitcoin yandex bitcoin hashrate bitcoin minergate bitcoin blender bitcoin банкомат bitcoin search bitcoin работа bitcoin bitcoin lurk bitcoin hash
fenix bitcoin rpc bitcoin tether 2 bitcoin монеты
bitcoin регистрация dog bitcoin local ethereum bitcoin people bitcoin click алгоритм bitcoin
finney ethereum q bitcoin bitcoin приложение secp256k1 bitcoin работа bitcoin bitcoin faucets bitcoin qr bitcoin вектор bitcoin de список bitcoin bitcoin clouding
lealana bitcoin котировки ethereum bitcoin развод разработчик bitcoin bitcoin plus trezor ethereum
bitcoin заработок daemon monero
hacking bitcoin обналичить bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin монеты tether приложение кран bitcoin What makes a double spend unlikely, though, is the size of the Bitcoin network. A so-called 51% attack, in which a group of miners theoretically control more than half of all network power, would be necessary. By controlling a majority of all network power, this group could dominate the remainder of the network to falsify records. However, such an attack on Bitcoin would require an overwhelming amount of effort, money, and computing power, thereby rendering the possibility extremely unlikely.13 14abi ethereum bitcoin q 1080 ethereum sportsbook bitcoin bitcoin red bio bitcoin bitcoin de joker bitcoin ethereum история bitcoin blue ebay bitcoin bitcoin коллектор mixer bitcoin electrum bitcoin cryptocurrency calculator bitcoin продам
eos cryptocurrency bitcoin клиент bitcoin обменники bitcoin ваучер платформ ethereum bitcoin loan bitcoin office monero обменник pdf bitcoin bitcoin uk bitcoin php uk bitcoin bitcoin валюта количество bitcoin bitcoin анимация работа bitcoin обналичить bitcoin
кран bitcoin bitcoin banking иконка bitcoin bitcoin 3 cryptocurrency tech ethereum логотип q bitcoin покер bitcoin 60 bitcoin
accepts bitcoin bitcoin cli iso bitcoin register bitcoin bitcoin шахты bitcoin сложность bitcoin flapper miner monero bitcoin хешрейт bitcoin london alpari bitcoin bitcoin ecdsa акции bitcoin ubuntu ethereum bitcoin разделился stats ethereum monero transaction
bitcoin fast bitcoin poloniex
monero usd bitcoin коллектор эмиссия ethereum
перевод ethereum
unconfirmed monero gui monero bitcoin haqida
machines bitcoin golang bitcoin
bitcoin atm bitcoin paper bitcoin alliance bitcoin king mac bitcoin bitcoin loan bitcoin майнеры mineable cryptocurrency 2018 bitcoin логотип ethereum london bitcoin bitcoin valet ethereum twitter кости bitcoin coffee bitcoin express bitcoin nanopool monero rx560 monero 4pda tether bitcoin ads monero usd etoro bitcoin ethereum asics ethereum обменять форумы bitcoin bitcoin оборудование ico bitcoin
ethereum проекты bitcoin co mercado bitcoin ethereum кошелек bitcoin eobot bitcoin qazanmaq
bitcoin server asrock bitcoin 4000 bitcoin planet bitcoin bitcoin рулетка up bitcoin
monero gpu tether mining raspberry bitcoin ethereum рост difficulty monero форк ethereum bitcoin cards tether верификация ethereum курс сайт ethereum waves bitcoin продать monero курс tether зебра bitcoin банкомат bitcoin bitcoin token simple bitcoin bitcoin allstars
bitcoin дешевеет bitcoin swiss
bitcoin кошелек forum ethereum конвертер ethereum bitcoin legal
transactions bitcoin ethereum serpent tp tether best bitcoin lealana bitcoin bitcoin описание bitcoin магазины обновление ethereum
maining bitcoin ethereum homestead bitcoin новости fake bitcoin bitcoin nvidia polkadot cadaver fasterclick bitcoin panda bitcoin bitcoin мошенники micro bitcoin seed bitcoin bitcoin payoneer bitcoin dance txid bitcoin bitcoin даром покупка ethereum connect bitcoin bitcoin комментарии алгоритм monero tracker bitcoin invest bitcoin birds bitcoin ethereum вывод in bitcoin wiki bitcoin instant bitcoin accepts bitcoin bitcoin 2018 bitcoin компьютер bazar bitcoin gadget bitcoin фарминг bitcoin вклады bitcoin bitcoin программа win bitcoin bitcoin play bitcoin greenaddress flappy bitcoin кран ethereum wallpaper bitcoin spots cryptocurrency bitcoin puzzle lucky bitcoin bitcoin ротатор accepts bitcoin ethereum алгоритм доходность ethereum kinolix bitcoin exchange bitcoin
hyip bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum bitcoin instagram bitcoin 30 биржи ethereum bitcoin форекс bistler bitcoin ethereum forum bitcoin minergate проекта ethereum запросы bitcoin bitcoin blocks bitcoin вектор цены bitcoin
bitcoin monero bitcoin покупка bitcoin landing bitcoin анонимность monero wallet byzantium ethereum iobit bitcoin start bitcoin qr bitcoin bitcoin formula
cardano cryptocurrency bitcoin dark
wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin стратегия автомат bitcoin bitcoin 4pda bitcoin sha256 сложность monero nodes bitcoin bitcoin vip roboforex bitcoin
ethereum ios рост ethereum настройка monero луна bitcoin monero валюта bitcoin adress ethereum calc avatrade bitcoin yota tether
bitcoin миксеры bitcoin комиссия bitcoin adress
polkadot su blake bitcoin jax bitcoin bitcoin play bitcoin rus
bitcoin кэш магазин bitcoin yota tether hacking bitcoin bitcoin vpn kurs bitcoin
bitcoin airbit raiden ethereum bitcoin miner pokerstars bitcoin
ethereum картинки
bitcoin rotator